Overview
Late at night in Barron County, Wisconsin, a couple watches as a rolled-up carpet is carted out of a nearby home. Soon after they learn the combative neighbor who lived there, Gary Herbst, is missing.
-
39 - 1The Boy Who Killed His Twin September 27, 2025 -
39 - 2Murder in the Parking Garage October 04, 2025 -
39 - 3A Death in the Stairwell October 11, 2025 -
39 - 4My Uncle Joe's Murder October 18, 2025 -
39 - 5Closing the Cold Case of Robin Lawrence October 25, 2025 -
39 - 6The Han Family Murders November 01, 2025 -
39 - 7Tracker Dakota Black November 08, 2025 -
39 - 8The Setup Murder of Kristil Krug November 15, 2025 -
39 - 9Help Find Molly Bish's Killer December 06, 2025 -
39 - 10Joe Hunter's Mission December 13, 2025 -
39 - 11Coached to Kill January 03, 2026 -
39 - 12The Gaslighting of Hannah Pettey January 10, 2026 -
39 - 13Melissa Rocuba's Final Moments January 17, 2026 -
39 - 14The Mother I Wish I Knew January 24, 2026 -
39 - 15The Sneak Attack on Katlyn Lyon January 31, 2026 -
39 - 16The Rx Defense February 07, 2026 -
39 - 17The Girl from Wahoo February 14, 2026 -
39 - 18Sade Robinson and the Secret Beach February 21, 2026 -
39 - 19The Woman Who Died Twice March 07, 2026 -
39 - 20Jocelyn Peters and the Notebook March 14, 2026 -
39 - 21What the Neighbors Saw March 21, 2026 -
39 - 22Denise and Aaron Quinn Get the Last Word March 28, 2026 -
39 - 23The Root Beer Float Murder April 04, 2026 -
39 - 24Kimberly Langwell’s Hidden Grave April 11, 2026